A judge denied the motion to dismiss a DRAM price-fixing lawsuit against Micron, Samsung and SK hynix, finding evidence of DRAM collusion plausible after a 500% price surge.
Judge Noël Wise, who presides over the proposed class-action lawsuit against Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix, has denied the companies' motion to have the case dismissed. According to the decision, the defendants' argument that the action is merely "a rerun" of the antitrust case filed against the industry in 2018 was rejected, because the plaintiffs have established that there is new evidence suggesting collusion among the big three memory chip manufacturers.
Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix argued that they watch each other closely because competition is so intense. Judge Wise disagreed with this characterization, saying that the accusations go beyond ordinary competitive awareness. "Their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation — an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do."
The plaintiffs, 17 individuals and small businesses, allege that the companies made four parallel moves that restricted DRAM supply and led to the current shortage, during which prices jumped by as much as 500% in one year. One cited event is the "simultaneous DRAM production cuts" from October 2022 to April 2023, which was quickly followed by a "coordinated pivot to HBM." The plaintiffs also say the three companies announced the winding down of DDR4 production within three months of each other and have failed to expand production capacity "despite these extraordinary prices — the single most powerful supply signal the DRAM industry has ever produced."
Other factors cited by the plaintiffs include the introduction of stringent customer vetting procedures in response to the shortage, the refusal to sign long-term contracts with DRAM customers, Micron's decision to shut down Crucial, its consumer memory brand, and multiple statements projecting the shortage. They also point to the companies' involvement in previous price-fixing scandals.
The memory makers argued that all of these actions are logical business decisions aimed at maximizing revenue during a period of strong demand, and that they are "consistent with [their own] independent self-interest." They also said their similar behavior is a product of operating in a highly concentrated market and of "reacting to the same market pressures," so it would make sense for them to respond in similar ways.
Despite these rebuttals, the judge found the case plausible enough to proceed. This is not a judgment on the merits, however. Both sides must still present their evidence and arguments before the court reaches a decision. The three companies have until December 7 to respond to the original complaint, and a case management conference, which will address administrative matters, is set for January 2027.